Good morning, everyone,
I took this photo of children playing in the Piazza in Siena, Italy on a bright, Sunday summer morning 7 years ago. I had been sitting on the cobbled piazza watching the Italians be Italian and this group of children playing, laughing, and having a wonderful time when this little girl suddenly stopped and turned her gaze to the ground, transfixed by the sight of a dead pigeon. The intensity of her gaze affected mine, and suddenly I, too, was transfixed.
Like this little girl, who was approximately the age of the children who have crept into our hearts and souls since Friday, I am often affected by images like this of a being stilled by death. I think it’s absolutely normal to try to make sense of it, to understand it, to wonder about it, to take the imagery in and process it in every way that we can.
One of the most striking videos I have ever seen was of a group of elephants who had come upon the desert-bleached bones of a member of their herd that had died the year before. The elder members of the herd touched the whitened bones with their trunks, picking them up and laying them down again, gently felt them with their huge feet…the babies of the herd coming over to investigate with just as much curiosity. And I have seen videos of various ape mothers unwilling to leave the lifeless bodies of their offspring. There is a natural process that has to happen in order to “move forward” and that time frame is different for everyone.
When I was growing up I remember my mother becoming completely absorbed in news coverage of tragedies involving families and children. She would sit in front of the television for what seemed an inordinate amount of time trying, I imagined, to make sense of it, perhaps reprocessing the sudden death of her husband – my father – and how life had changed in an instant when he died.
As the years passed, whenever I would hear about a terminally ill relative of a friend, I would feel slightly envious that they would have time to process the inevitable saying of goodbye while the person was still alive, thinking that it would be such a blessing to be certain to leave no words, no feelings, no thoughts, no sentiments unexpressed before the final goodbye.
I do not know how it is possible to process the death of someone one loves when it is entirely unexpected, as so many families in Connecticut are now doing. But I do know that it is not something that can be rushed or forced or pushed or set on automatic…like the weaponry that did the deed.
It is so easy to look the other way when it gets to be uncomfortable and too painful to look at. It is so easy to switch to another channel in our heads. It is so easy not to tarry too long there in the discomfort zone. Two of this little girl’s friends were oblivious, not sharing or sensing her kinetic fascination with the earthbound body of a creature pulled irrevocably from its life’s flight. Yet one little girl caught her friend’s gaze and took it in ever so sweetly and gently, in solidarity, perhaps, and understanding. I wish that I had had a video camera, because the moment lingered well past the instant I took this photo, until the two girls gathered themselves together once again and ran off to catch up with their playmates.
Such a running off is natural for children, who must, like all of us, deal with reality, but who must also, hopefully, be allowed to return to moments of joy and innocence and playing free of worry.
But now I wonder about us…as adults…and think it isn’t so wise to run away from what happened this week, returning so quickly to the regular tempo of our lives, as though this is just the way of it. Maybe we are meant to tarry over this event long enough to change and challenge our assumption that it will just happen again and again and again, because that’s they way life is, because we’ve become used to this sort of thing, because we’ve come to not only expect it, but to accept it.
Whenever one visits a piazza in Italy, one expects to see a dead pigeon or two.
But whenever one visits a schoolyard, one does not expect to contemplate the reality of dead children.
We should never get used to such things.
It is unacceptable for us to move on like nothing happened, like this has become our new normal.
Perhaps we should be more like the elephants, touching the event and giving honor to it for however long it takes us to change our collective future as peaceful citizens of Planet Earth. We need to promise one another something different.
We need to stare for a while and try to make sense of it before moving on.
Have a lovely Sunday, all…and thank you for reading, as always…
Giselle
#Newtown
December 16, 2012 at 3:15 pm
Morning
December 16, 2012 at 3:15 pm
Beautiful post.
December 16, 2012 at 3:15 pm
Giselle Minoli Touching photo. Beautifully enhanced by your narrative. Perfect for this mourning.
December 16, 2012 at 3:22 pm
Not surprisingly each persons mourning process and time is different. And even different for different relationships. Some people get over it quickly. Others never seem to get over it. And some can’t start their grieving process. They experience a blockage they cannot comprehend.
In some middle eastern cultures, and especially in the olden times, when most of the folk neither had the luxury nor the time to grieve they would gather together, in their black mourning clothes, and wail together. When I was younger I’d observe this and not understand why they were doing this. Why they were beating themselves on their chests, or on their legs, and crying. Some of them even appeared to be doing it to themselves by force.
Then it dawned on me. If people didn’t grieve then they would be indefinitely sick. And not just psychologically, but also physiologically. Often contributing to a shortening of their own lives. Grieving was important. It was necessary. And thus this type of grieving must have developed to aid the survivors to initiate and release their grieving. To begin the process of catharsis.
People grieve differently in different cultures. But they all need to grieve.
The ceremonies that cultures carry out to aid the grieving are there for more than just show. They’re there to aid a community back to health.
December 16, 2012 at 3:30 pm
Thank you Melanie McRae and Mike Byrnes and Satyr Icon for taking the time to read. Yes, Satyr, it is different for each of us. We are none of us the same and I hope that we can individually and collectively honor those differences. Yet somehow this is something that we should all be grieving. Yes, it happened specifically to certain children and certain families, but we are indeed all one…and it has happened to the community in which we all live and dream for a peaceful future. I do not think we can have that future if we turn away too quickly from what has happened this week. Thank you for your words.
December 16, 2012 at 3:30 pm
Beautifully eloquent as always Giselle Minoli.
December 16, 2012 at 3:31 pm
I have missed your words so much Giselle and these are so important. This event has rocked me to my core…I don’t want to move past it with my busyness of life. Instead, I am choosing to let this tragedy seep deep into my heart, pause at length to acknowledge its significance, and stay open to how it should, and must change me.
December 16, 2012 at 3:37 pm
Dear Tom Moncho and Ardith Goodwin thank you both so much for visiting with my little Siena girl this morning. I am so with you, Ardith…I am right there with you. I know so very many, many people are all over the world. I posted Limited and Public about this Friday and in a comment I said that I think there is something about this that could change the tide for us all. I sincerely am hopeful it might finally be possible….
December 16, 2012 at 3:37 pm
Thank you, Giselle.
December 16, 2012 at 3:54 pm
Wonderful words, Giselle Minoli . If we call ourselves “an advanced society”, the least we should do is sit down, reflect on the facts and find a solution for situations like these never to happen again.
December 16, 2012 at 4:27 pm
Most thoughtful Giselle Minoli . I posted something yesterday much less eloquent but I had a similar thought– we need to contemplate this well beyond the all-too-familiar packaging provided by the news cycle.
Thanks for writing and happy Sunday to you.
December 16, 2012 at 4:33 pm
I hope you are right Giselle Minoli that this may, just may, be the catalyst for some change. Enough is enough. We need to start acting like a civilized society!
You also raise the issue of dealing with a sudden and unexpected death and trying to come to terms with it. Having been through the shock and disbelief of hearing the words “she didn’t make it” myself, I know that hearing those words — when you hear them completely unexpectedly — changes you forever. Whenever there is a tragedy like this, I am reminded yet again and the words ring in my mind over and over again.
December 16, 2012 at 4:35 pm
way to go Giselle Minoli – you have again touched all of us with elegance. i was thinking about trying to write something on this subject and couldn’t imagine an approach –
December 16, 2012 at 4:57 pm
“We need to promise ourselves something different”
Amen!
#goodpeople
December 16, 2012 at 5:54 pm
Please read this article. Be vocal and ask for changes in laws http://m.gawker.com/5968818/i-am-adam-lanzas-mother
December 16, 2012 at 6:27 pm
Giselle Minoli You have said so eloquently what I have been feeling. That we as a society need to sit and be with this, with the loss, the grief, the profound sadness, the helplessness and vulnerability, the fear, as hard as it is. It is only then, that true answers will come, after the stages of the grieving process. We need not to skip over them, even though it may seem more comfortable in the here and now.
I think the news media feeds into the problem of violence by giving publicity to the names of shooters, and so they know they will go out with the attention they were not receiving in their troubled lives. I think the media needs to stop giving the shooters a name, and rather honor the names to the victims and their families.
I do believe we as a society have a huge problem in how we deal with mental illness and family dysfunction. We ignore, stigmatize, fail to diagnose or properly treat…. We de-institutionalized the severely mentally ill back in the Reagan years. If I walk around the down town of my city, I am accosted by psychotics living on the streets. They are the tip on the iceberg.
As nurse, I did a lot of continuing education in mental health, specifically regards to family dysfunction, abuse, attachment disorder, and chronic PTSD. Troubled families are surprisingly common, and I believe this is where the predisposing vulnerability towards becoming violent begins. Add to that the narcissism and violence of popular culture…..
December 16, 2012 at 6:45 pm
Matthew Graybosch I don’t separate out for one minute the sadness I feel for the shooter and his family and mother from what I feel for these children. The only separation I make is that these children are not and were not responsible for the policies of our country toward those who are mentally unstable. And so, in a way, I think the empathy that we need to feel for them and their families needs to be honored in and of itself. The young man who did this and his mother are also dead. And that is also a tragedy. I have not heard it absolutely confirmed that he had untreated Asperger’s, but even if it is true I worry about the consequences of blame implied in that. There are plenty of people with emotional disorders who are being treated and do take responsibility for their health who are not going out and killing people. I think there are two distinctly separate issues here.
The issue that we as a culture face that to me is the most serious, the most crucial, is one of cynicism and anger. Neither will move us forward to a heightened awareness of mental disorders. Neither will move us toward programs to help those are in need. We cannot legislate sensitivity or caring. We cannot make every mother and every father with a disturbed child see that disturbance and act on it to prevent something like this from happening.
But…we can make it less easy for people to get their hands on weaponry that, if placed in the hands of people who are not in control of themselves, will wreck the kind of pain and sorrow that washed over this community in Connecticut on Friday morning.
For us to pretend that we cannot make such legislation possible is, forgive me, BS. We want everything. We cannot have everything. I’m sorry, but the argument that people will always get their hands on weaponry doesn’t wash with me and it is, in my opinion, a cowardly excuse to back away from the table where the difficult questions are asked.
This event is the table. And we need to all sit at it and not get up until we have shifted the policies in another direction.
December 16, 2012 at 7:02 pm
Asperger’s doesn’t make a person violent or mentally unstable. Having an untreated learning difference , though, (giftedness not recognized etc) can lead to undesirable emotional and social growth. But I really tke exception to the media labeling this boy with an unconfirmed and undiagnosed condition that is in no way a precursor to violence and instability. It is already so little understood by the media and masses
December 16, 2012 at 7:08 pm
Hi, miriam dunn I am SO WITH YOU on this. I watched an interview last night with this young man’s Aunt (the sister of his mother, I believe) and she was asked repeatedly if anything had ever been said to her, if there had ever been any indication and all said was that he was quiet and very (very) smart. I remember quite unlike this incident the analysis of the boy who did the deed at Virginia Tech, where there was a long history of emotional problems prior that had students worried, but where the boy had also been marginalized to a degree, that seems to indicate opposite ends of the spectrum.
It is not clear at all that anyone ever turned their back on this young man, and if it is true that will, hopefully, come out as times goes on. Even if it is true, these children are still innocent and that is undeniable.
December 16, 2012 at 7:12 pm
miriam dunn I didn’t want to go there – just yet – but I wish the medial would stick to the objective and leave their opinions in the editorial pages.
December 16, 2012 at 7:20 pm
Well, Anita Law, you hit the core of it. It is painful. My husband’s son is driving North today…it’s raining…and I’ve been thinking about him (as I know Brian Altman is) and that knowledge…the knowledge of how fragile and unpredictable it all is…this is what has gripped me. I remember my mother telling me how long it took it to sink in that Dad had died. You must have felt the same way in what you describe.
This appreciation of life, and our individual and collective ability to be supportive of one another when it ends…this is what is important.
December 16, 2012 at 7:29 pm
Giselle Minoli I live a not many towns over from Newtown in CT. I know people in that town. My mother in-law is a 1st grade teacher in my small town. My niece is a 3rd grader in my mother in-laws elementary school. I was at her Christmas concert earlier in the week and laughed with joy along with my wife watching the kindergarten and 1st graders singing. To think that 2 days later similar children would be slaughtered is excruciating.
I’ve been in a state of sorrow, grief, anger and horror for a third day. My tears have been an equal amount or more to 9/11. My heart goes out to the families involved for all the victims, the first responders…. and for a society that just lost the most precious jewels we have.
December 16, 2012 at 7:35 pm
Hi, Nick Markwell I needed to read your words. I hate feeling that women are more against gun control than men. I want to be wrong about that feeling. And I do believe that eventually it will change. Funny how when someone like Michael J. Fox gets a disease himself he gets deeply involved in researching a cure. This happens in medicine frequently. But what famous person or powerful politician or public figure is going to have to lose a loved one at the hands of a gunman to finally push for the kind of reform that we need? Why does it so often take something like that to turn the tide?
December 16, 2012 at 7:38 pm
Hi James Barraford I have been thinking about you this week and apologize for not having been in touch to ask how close by you are. Whenever anything happens in Connecticut I think of you! I can only imagine how you feel. The proximity must make this all the more powerful to you. Well, know only that your empathy and tears are felt in ways unknown to you a few towns over. What you feel matters a great deal.
December 16, 2012 at 7:46 pm
Giselle Minoli The similarities to my town, combined with living not far from the situation, has made it difficult to escape. I have a segment of friends that are schoolteachers very near to Newtown that are going to have a few tough weeks ahead. I saw my niece last night at a family gathering and embarrassed her with my hugging and kissing. I didn’t care. 🙂
December 16, 2012 at 8:00 pm
I vote for infinite amounts of hugging and kissing James Barraford. May the hugging and kissing never stop.
December 16, 2012 at 8:04 pm
miriam dunn To clarify…If shooter were to have AS, and had not been worked with, he may have had issues with socialization, isolation, bullying, and those secondary issues can lead to rage and acting out. And in our culture of violence…. I am not excusing them, or blaming AS. But my understanding is some with AS do need social skills training. And families are often in denial. I hope the truth will come out.
December 16, 2012 at 8:12 pm
A very poignant post Giselle Minoli. I found it so hard to accept the death of Princess Dianna years ago, and John Lennon before that. It couldn’t be real, but it was. It was final and there was nothing anybody could do. Sad that John Lennon died at the hand of someone with a mental disorder who gained access to firearms. I was thinking yesterday how each of these mass shootings are becoming more and more gruesome and shocking. Will we ever turn the corner on this? Will we ever be able to come together? There is nothing United about these States at the moment except our shared grief, and that’s sad because innocent children are dying. This morning when we were having breakfast by the lake, a family arrived to sit on the patio outside and there were several little girls about the age of the victims of the Newtown tragedy. Looking at them I can’t wrap my mind around the act of killing a child. How terrifying for those kids. One minute they were being happy little kids, and the next they discovered that monsters really do exist and humans are capable the most heinous and despicable acts. May they all rest in peace.
December 16, 2012 at 9:10 pm
Gary Stockton I remember well the death of Princess Diana. Christie’s in New York had sold her collection of gowns not long before and so it seemed particularly “close.” I remember much cynicism about the media coverage…she was just a princess, why all the upset over her death as opposed to any “normal” person’s. Yet it was not that she was so special, or more special than anyone else, but more that the public knowledge of her made it easier to galvanize feelings around something so absurd as her car being chased through a tunnel that would result in her death. So many people go unmourned. I think there is something unifying about it when an entire country weeps, as with Princess Diana, or JFK, or, well, there are so many I don’t want to get in trouble for leaving someone out.
The point is that we are desensitized to it. We have whether we want to admit it or not, become used to it and I hear people all too often say that we should get used to it. This is the essence of cynicism and I think we should all guard against it lest we turn ourselves into stone.
December 16, 2012 at 9:20 pm
Matthew Graybosch Turns out the altercation never happened. Like a lot of reports, it was wrong. We need to help those with mental illness in a non-judgmental manner. Prison isn’t help, it’s warehousing after the fact.
December 16, 2012 at 9:22 pm
I don’t think I’ve really allowed my mind to fully ‘go there’ just yet. I have an 8 year old 3rd grader, and my college-student daughter’s work study program has her with a class of 1st graders several times per week. My ex-wife’s mother and my wife’s mother were both elementary school teachers. I simply can’t process it now, and I can’t imagine what the people affected must be dealing with.
At this point, we’ve decided to try to shield the little one from as much information as we can. As far as we know, he has not learned of it. Not sure how long we can keep the shield around him, but I don’t see anything good coming from him hearing about this. I’m wondering what others with young ones are doing. The school sent an email today saying they will not be talking about in class tomorrow, which I think is the right thing to do.
December 16, 2012 at 9:49 pm
For those of you who are interested, I had tried to find the exact elephant video I referred to, but couldn’t. This one is very similar. I remember seeing several at the time, perhaps by the same film company, and it’s interesting to watch (elephants are fascinating creatures): Elephants grieving – BBC wildlife
December 17, 2012 at 12:36 am
You are correct: we should never get used to such things
Otherwise, that is a beautiful post and reflection upon so many things human.
December 17, 2012 at 12:52 am
President Obama is about to address the live Memorial Service In Connecticut for the children who lost their lives on Friday. This is the link: http://www.abc2news.com/generic/news/news_livestream1/Live-streaming-video
December 17, 2012 at 12:58 am
I have no idea what the words mean, but the most beautiful Hebrew Prayer is being sung at this moment…
December 17, 2012 at 12:58 am
Watching now, thanks Giselle.
December 17, 2012 at 4:30 am
I placed all of their pictures in an album so that I can see them and remember. I choose not to let their memory fade into my busy life. This must be different and I simply want to ‘see’ them and remember that the most important change I can make is to love thy neighbor.
December 17, 2012 at 4:37 am
Ardith Goodwin I’ve been trying to sleep for an hour now, lying there, thinking about how random and strange life is at the same time that we must have a purpose to our lives, something that carries us forward, into the night, into the morning, into the next day. And, Yes, to Love Thy Neighbor as Thyself, because we are all connected, you are right, this is the way to remember them.
I think I woke up to read your words before beginning another day, another week. Thank you….
December 17, 2012 at 4:40 am
You are so welcome. I have been attacked verbally by friends on that other network who ‘don’t want the images of those babies haunting them for the rest of their lives.” I am like…really? How tragic. We must remember these beautiful souls, we must go on from here with the resolve to love more and better than we have. Glad my words helped, yours did as well.
December 17, 2012 at 4:47 am
You. Are. Kidding. That reminds me, Ardith Goodwin of Barbara Bush saying that she didn’t want to waste her beautiful mind viewing body bags and caskets of soldiers being brought back from Iraq. Right. Well, that is exactly why things like this continue to happen. People turn away and the problem continues unabated. I spend no time on that other network.
December 17, 2012 at 4:47 am
That’s a great way to carry their memory Ardith, I hope we can someday have a national memorial dedicated to them. A place for teachers and children to be honored and remembered.
December 17, 2012 at 4:53 am
Earlier on the other network, some of my “friends” were upset that the presidential seal and podium were at the service. They felt Obama was there for himself, and should have been there not as a politician. I shut down in that exchange right away.
December 17, 2012 at 4:59 am
Gary Stockton I just do not think it’s possible to separate out these issues. If someone is hit by a drunk driver, it’s difficult to separate out the sadness about their death from the rage at the driver. If a woman is killed by someone from whom she had sought protection from, it’s difficult to separate out the sadness about her death from the rage that she couldn’t be protected. This is not the same thing as a child, no matter how horrifying, dying of a disease that took their young life all too soon. This kind of tragedy is very much on the national stage…the one where private mourning, public mourning, politics, legislation and the need for change all intermingle and convene. I’m not sure it should be otherwise. I don’t have the answer here, but it seems inevitable that the mourning and the “politics” of it had to come together.
December 17, 2012 at 5:06 am
I agree. Final comment over on that FB thread came from someone who said “As somebody who used to live in Newtown and has a friend there that has a kid in that school I find this discussion deplorable. All of you need to grow up.” Which was how I felt about it. They just can’t pass up an opportunity to bag on our President. Why do I even associate with these people?
December 17, 2012 at 12:33 pm
Gary Stockton When Bush spoke at 911 memorials the presidential seal was used. I’m guessing those same people had no problem with it then.
December 30, 2015 at 12:19 pm
Well